Sanity Test for Dung Beetle Dash! - The Card Game

77/100
Final Score
A fun theme and graphics. The rules and shop page are well-written and only need minor tweaks.
Completed November 16, 2018 by CrassPip

Rules 59/80

Structure 7/9

Good. You could consider adding a table of contents since it's a pretty long rulebook. As mentioned later, having a more explicit end game section would also be good.

Requirements 3/3

Fine.

Introduction 3/3

Excellent. One question.. Why should we thank them?

Overview 2/3

Between the intro and The Goal, there is an adequate overview.

Component List 4/5

Stickers are mentioned on the shop page but not in the component list.

Component Pictures 2/3

Not needed.

Setup 8/10

(Note that Setup is more correct for this section than Set-up.)
2: Shuffle, deal, then put them next to the dung pile. (It's hard to deal when the pile is on the table already.)
"Keep Power Cards hidden from view": This sentence could be interpreted in different ways. I think you mean players can look at their cards but should keep them private.

Setup Pictures 5/7

Token Stickers: The "Flip" having the bug on it looks weird, especially on the dung tokens. I'd just label the images Front and Back.

Game Play 10/15

Steps 2 and 3 are not really different steps of a standard turn; they are optional paths depending on the situation. I would label these 2A and 2B.
Step 1: "If you play your Power Card, you can draw a new one from the pile to replace it immediately or when your turn ends": Decide which it will be and make that the rule. It probably makes sense to do it at the end since that step is to ensure you have 2 cards.
Step 2: "To get to the Pile and reveal a Dung Ball Token, reveal one card on your turn until you get a total of 3 or more distance points.": This sentence is confusing. You've already given the instruction to reveal a card. Don't restate it. Something like "If the total of your revealed cards is 3 or more, you've reached the dung pile" would be better.
Step 3: Ditto. Also, it was a little confusing that rollin'/stashing are named as two things but only take one set of cards to complete. (At first I thought you need to roll back to the burrow and then flip more cards to stash.)
Step 4: As part of the last step, I would add to check for a win. I assume that the game ends immediately if you get to 5 or more points.
Beetle Battle: "Battling can be done only if you are DASHIN'": Battles can only be initiated when you are dashin'. The target can be rollin'.
Step 1-3: All of this seems extra verbose. The Beetle Battle is just a power card, so it follows the standard rules, (play one per turn, play it and discard it.)
"The beetle that lands on it’s feet wins the round. “Best 2 of 3” rounds wins.": This description isn't adequate. What if both land on their feet on the first round? Is that considered a win for both so the second flip determines the winner? It seems like there are going to be a lot of ties.
If you are battled against: Loser: "If you were battled against and lose, you lose ALL your Dung Balls to the other player’s Burrow": Surely you only mean the ones you were rolling, not the ones you already had stashed?
Champ o the Heap: "The “Champ o the Heap” Power Card is different from the “Tractor Beetle” card." Why does this need to be said?
Multi-Beetle: So this lets you break the rule of one power card per turn but you still can't do two battles? Can you do a Beetle Battle and Champ o' the Heap?

Game Play Pictures 5/7

Images aren't really needed, but the ones that are there add some color and fun.

End Point 2/6

The should be an End Game section. At minimum you need to address the question of whether the game ends immediately. (If it does, it seems like there is a big first player advantage.)

Overall Comprehension 3/4

Most of the questions above are fairly minor.

Clarity 3/3

"It's" means "it is." The possessive is "its." Think of his, hers, theirs, all with no apostrophe. Its is the same.

Presentation 2/2

Good.

Shop Presentation 18/20

Ad 3/3

Excellent image. Good text.

Backdrop 1/1

I'd check it on a small screen like a phone and iPad to make sure it looks ok.

Logo 1/1

Fine.

Action Shots 4/5

I'll reiterate that you should have a picture of the game in play.

Description 5/5

Tells about gameplay in a fun and engaging way.

Video 4/5

The sound quality of the voiceover could be better. As mentioned, the video is a little slow. The pile setup has changed.


Community Chat